|
|
Sienna Cloud for NDI |
NDIPE SRT-MPEGTS |
SiennaLink Servertor |
NDIPE SiennaLink |
NDIPE NDI over SRT |
Feature |
|
# Channels |
|
unlimited |
unlimited |
ONE |
unlimited |
unlimited |
Auto Discovery |
|
YES |
NO |
NO |
NO |
NO |
Centralised
Single Point of Config |
YES |
NO |
NO |
NO |
NO |
On Demand
Source Selection |
YES |
NO |
NO |
NO |
NO |
Multicam Sync |
|
YES |
NO |
NO |
NO |
NO |
Remote PTZ
Camera Control |
YES |
NO |
NO |
NO |
YES |
Remote Tally |
|
YES |
NO |
NO |
NO |
YES |
Retain Alpha Channel |
|
YES |
NO |
NO |
NO |
YES |
GOP
Structure Protection |
YES* |
NO |
YES* |
YES* |
YES |
QOS Monitoring |
|
Real Time Stats in Web GUI |
SRT Stats |
NO |
SRT Stats |
SRT Stats |
Bandwidth Control |
|
YES |
YES |
YES |
YES |
NO |
Encoding
Parameter Control |
PRESETS |
FULL |
PRESETS |
PRESETS |
N/A |
Simple Relay
(no transcode) |
NO |
YES |
NO |
NO |
YES |
Port Forwarding |
|
Either Side |
Receiver Side |
Server Side |
Server Side |
Either Side |
Transport |
|
StreamCertain (Discrete Essence) |
SRT (MPEG Transport Stream) |
SRT (Discrete Essence) |
SRT (Discrete Essence) |
SRT (Native NDI Essence) |
Codec |
|
H.264 |
Typically H.264 |
H.264 |
H.264 |
NDI / NDI HX2 |
Audio |
|
PCM |
Typically AAC |
PCM |
PCM |
NDI Native |
License |
|
All Nodes |
All Nodes |
Server Side Only |
Server Side Only |
All Nodes |
Latency |
|
very low |
low (very low for simple relay) |
very low |
very low |
very,very low |
WAN Protocol
Compatibility |
Another NDI.Cloud Node |
Most SRT Devices (MPEG TS) |
SiennaLink Client/RX |
SiennaLink Client/RX |
Another ND Processing Engine |
End Point
Compatibility |
NDI |
Various NDI, MPEG TS, etc |
NDI |
NDI |
NDI |
Server Platform |
|
Mac, Linux |
MLinux |
Mac, Windows, Linux |
Linux |
Linux |
Target |
|
Facilities or OB Van Interconnect |
Ad-hoc Wan connection |
Remote Edit Monitoring |
Remote Monitoring / Video Links |
Full Bandwidth Low Latency Links |
|
* GOP
Structure Protection : Even when bandwidth is consistently insufficient, the
GOP structure will never breakup - it will just drop frames at the source
before encoding |
Systems from other vendors will break the GOP structure where bandwidth is consistently
insufficient, even with reliable protocols like SRT |
|